You are on our german site.

Blog

Separating from Managing Directors – Sequence Matters

lit_portraits_840x840px_babat.png Roschan Babat

November 2026

Estimated read time: Min

Starting Point: Removal from Office Does Not Terminate the Underlying Contract

In Germany, it is important to distinguish between a managing director’s corporate office and the underlying service or employment contract. These two legal relationships exist independently of one another. As a rule, removal from office only ends the appointment as managing director (Section 38 GmbHG). The underlying contractual relationship generally continues and must be terminated separately. The managing director may perform their duties under an independent service agreement or an employment contract.

No General Protection Against Dismissal for Managing Directors

As a rule, managing directors do not enjoy protection against dismissal under the KSchG. Where they work under an independent service agreement, the KSchG does not apply in the first place, as it requires an employment relationship.

In practice, however, managing directors frequently work under an employment contract. Even then, they may not enjoy protection against dismissal despite the existence of an employment relationship. This follows from Section 14 (1) No. 1 KSchG, which excludes the statutory representatives of a legal entity, including the managing directors of a GmbH, from general protection against dismissal for the duration of their appointment.

In a recent judgment dated June 18, 2026 (2 AZR 89/25), the Federal Labor Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht, “BAG”) clarified that, in such circumstances, the exclusion of protection against dismissal under Section 14 (1) No. 1 KSchG depends on whether the individual still holds office when notice of termination is received:

  • If the managing director still holds office when notice of termination is received, Section 14 (1) No. 1 KSchG applies. The termination does not require social justification, even though an employment relationship exists.

  • If notice of termination is received only after removal from office, the statutory exclusion under Section 14 (1) No. 1 KSchG no longer applies. Termination of the underlying employment relationship must be socially justified.

The decision therefore confirms the importance of getting the sequence right, particularly where the contractual relationship between the parties qualifies as an employment relationship.

In the BAG case cited above, the managing director was removed from office in February 2023 but did not receive notice of termination until June 2023. The BAG found that the underlying relationship was an employment relationship, in part because the parties had repeatedly referred to their relationship as an “employment relationship,” the contract as an “employment contract,” and the claimant as an “employee.” The termination therefore required social justification. As no such justification existed, the termination was invalid.

Employment Relationship or Independent Service Relationship – Differences and Similarities in the Approach

Companies should carefully plan removal from office and termination of the underlying contract in every case. The specific steps depend on the nature of the contractual relationship:

  • Where an employment relationship exists, particular attention must be paid to the sequence described above. For the exclusion under Section 14 (1) No. 1 KSchG to apply, the managing director must receive notice of termination no later than at the same time as the declaration of removal from office.

  • Where an independent service relationship exists, general protection against dismissal does not apply because there is no employment relationship. Neither Section 14 (1) No. 1 KSchG nor the sequence of removal from office and termination is therefore relevant.

Particularly in the latter situation, continued work after removal from office should be avoided wherever possible. If it is necessary, for example for a handover, the duties should remain as close as possible to the individual’s previous duties as managing director. In particular, taking on new duties subject to instructions creates a risk of establishing an employment relationship.

Previous Employment Contracts: Have They Actually Been Terminated?

Before any separation, the contractual basis must be carefully reviewed. If the managing director was previously an employee, their appointment alone does not terminate the previous employment contract. Under BAG case law, however, entering into a written managing director service agreement with the same employer terminates the previous employment relationship unless otherwise agreed. A merely oral agreement on the new contractual arrangements is insufficient to terminate the previous employment relationship (Section 623 BGB).

An employment relationship expressly suspended under a written service agreement may also become relevant when notice of termination is given. Companies should therefore review the full contractual history. This is particularly important where the managing director previously worked for the same company in a different role.

Observe the Rules on Authority and Formal Requirements

As a rule, the shareholders’ meeting is responsible for removing the managing director from office and terminating the managing director’s service agreement. Any differing provisions in the articles of association must be observed. The articles may, for example, assign this responsibility to a supervisory or advisory board.

If the managing director works under an employment contract, responsibility for terminating each of the contractual relationships concerned must be clarified. The shareholders’ meeting’s authority may also extend to terminating the underlying employment relationship by virtue of its so-called ancillary competence (Annexkompetenz). The company’s managing directors are responsible for terminating an “ordinary” employment relationship. It may therefore be advisable to have the termination letter additionally signed by the company’s managing directors.

Notice of termination of an employment relationship must comply with the written-form requirement (Section 623 BGB). The recipient must receive the original termination letter bearing a handwritten signature. An email or a scanned copy is insufficient. For independent service agreements, the contractual form requirements must be checked.

Practical Checklist for Companies

  • Fully review the contractual basis and the development of the contractual relationships.

  • Check the applicable notice periods.

  • Clarify the required resolutions, authority to represent the company, powers of attorney, and formal requirements.

  • Where an employment relationship exists, arrange and document receipt of the notice of termination and the declaration of removal from office in the correct sequence.

  • Avoid continued work after removal from office wherever possible.

Conclusion: Review the Contractual Basis Before Taking Action

Before removing a managing director from office with a view to terminating the underlying contract, companies should establish the contractual basis and determine the steps to be taken. Careful preparation helps avoid errors concerning authority, formal requirements, and receipt of the relevant notices. A termination agreement may facilitate the process.

Do you have further questions on this topic?

Get in touch with us. We will support you individually with your employment law challenges as an employer.
Find a contact near you